Logo 
Search:

Unix / Linux / Ubuntu Forum

Ask Question   UnAnswered
Home » Forum » Unix / Linux / Ubuntu       RSS Feeds

GPL, lpr and copyright by Apple?

  Date: Dec 17    Category: Unix / Linux / Ubuntu    Views: 363
  

Something trivial thought it got me wondering since the way I
understand it is that Ubuntu is a OS that subscribes to the GPL.

I happened to look a the man page for the lpr command on my Ubuntu 8.04 system.

And at the bottom of the man page, this text appears:

> COPYRIGHT
> Copyright 2007 by Apple Inc.

This raises many questions.

1) Is the lpr command not an old *nix command that predates Apple OS X
by many years?
2) How come this is included in Ubuntu if Ubuntu is GPL?
3) Broadly speaking, it is a sad day if on the one side Microsoft
claims copyright on Linux and on the other side Apple actually manage
to insert their copyright statements right within OSS software.

What is up with this?

Share: 

 

2 Answers Found

 
Answer #1    Answered On: Dec 17    

I don't think that Ubuntu claims to be fully GPL, or even fully Open Source.
For that, you need to use a variant called Gobuntu:

www.ubuntu.com/products/whatisubuntu/gobuntu

Now, when Apple built OS X, they based it on the Berkeley Software
Distribution (BSD) and later, certain parts from FreeBSD's and
NetBSD's implementation of Unix in Nextstep (being the OS Jobs
developed for his NeXT machines, after he left Apple in 1985, or
thereabouts). Mac OS X was originally written for use on the old
PowerPC hardware, rather than Intel, and would have likely been
rewritten and optimised to make it run more efficiently ... then,
eventually ported. Sounds like they've released a whole bunch of this
stuff into the wild, hence the copyright legend.

If you look hard enough within the OS (Linux), you may find copyrights
beloning to a whole host of companies, such as the University of
California at Berkley AT&T Bell Laboratories, Sun Microsystems,
Hewlett Packard, IBM and Carnegie Mellon (amongst others) - you'll
find these in most Unix OS variants, being the historical developers
and maintainers of Unix.

I think that Microsoft are trying to claim copyright/ownership due to
the fact that they originally developed a Unix variant OS some years
ago, called Xenix. BG wasn't happy about having to pay royalties to
AT&T, et al, for every copy he sold, so sold it on to somebody called
the Santa Cruz Operation, where it became developed into SCO Unix.
Also one of the main reasons that Microsoft were so keen to throw a
lot of funding behind SCO's recent ownership claims ...

 
Answer #2    Answered On: Dec 17    

The CUPS source code is owned by Apple. They bought it in 2007 long after it was
in common use by not only Ubuntu but just about every open source company.
Because it is owned, copyright credit must be given.

 
Didn't find what you were looking for? Find more on GPL, lpr and copyright by Apple? Or get search suggestion and latest updates.




Tagged: